Site Name

Nolan's Odyssey

Finally got to watch Nolan’s Odyssey after much delay. Kind of funny, because the last two years have been full of Odyssey otherwise.

  • Read Benjamin The Odyssey through Gillian Cross’s children’s book.
  • Finished Dan Simmons’s Ilium and Olympos, which shove the characters of the Iliad and Odyssey straight into sci-fi.
  • That led directly to Tennyson’s Ulysses, which is quite good. “It little profits that an idle king…”
  • More amusingly, The Rest Is History podcast covered it in two fun parts. Clearly Odysseus’s crew were all Australians.

Changes I liked

  • Fewer gods. Totally sensible for realism.
  • Circe. More grotesque than seductive. A fun reinterpretation.
  • Lotus-Eaters and Calypso combined. Good compression. The movie was already three hours long.
  • Streamlined cast. Cutting the Phaeacians, Nestor, and Laertes saves time without losing much.
  • Never seeing Agamemnon’s face. Nice touch.

Changes I didn’t like

  • No “Nobody” trick with the Cyclops. Classic Odysseus: cleverness undermined by pride.
  • No Aeolus or bag of winds. A fun adventure lost. Maybe a missed opportunity for some comedy.
  • No dead Achilles. Especially disappointing given Nolan’s emphasis on the costs of war. Achilles’s ghost explicitly rejects the glory of dying in battle.
  • Telemachus diminished. Less capable and independent than in Homer.
  • No Penelope banter or olive-tree bed trick. We lose the wonderful sense that Penelope is Odysseus’s intellectual equal.
  • Sailing west. After ten years desperately trying to get home, Odysseus immediately leaves again? My wife: “Why would he get on another boat?!”

Ambivalent

  • Odysseus’s PTSD. Making the Trojan War something he regrets didn’t really stick with me, but maybe that says more about me than Homer. The whole “we are the Sea Peoples” angle seemed a bit much.

Sad Odysseus